Sales conversations are a series of make-or-break moments. Either you capture a buyer’s attention and make your value clear—or you lose them. 

The reality? Most sales reps are losing them.

Buyers today demand more than a product pitch—they want a partner who understands their goals. In fact, 86% of business buyers say they’re more likely to buy from a company that understands them and their needs, according to Salesforce. Yet, 59% say most sales reps don’t bother to know answers to questions that could be answered with basic research.

That disconnect is a sales killer, and asking a few questions can make a big difference. 

59% of business buyers say most sales reps don’t bother to know answers to questions that could be answered with basic research. — Salesforce

If your sales value proposition focuses too much on your company, your product, or your process, you’re missing the mark. The only thing your buyer cares about is this: “So what?” How does this help me? Why should I care?

If you can’t answer that question clearly, your pitch falls flat. 

I’ve spent my career studying what separates top salespeople from the rest, and it usually comes down to the ability to deliver the right words, at the right time, in the right way in the form of a compelling value proposition. I’ve discovered there are five mistakes that sellers regularly make in their communication with buyers that weaken their value proposition. 

5 Common Mistakes That Weaken Your Sales Value Proposition

Your sales value proposition is the key to grabbing a buyer’s attention—and keeping it. Make sure you aren’t committing one of these errors and causing buyers to turn away before conversations even get started. 

Mistake #1: Making It About You, Not the Buyer

Buyers don’t care about your company’s history. They don’t care about your revenue growth. They don’t even care about your product—until they understand how it helps them.

Yet, many salespeople make the same mistake: They lead with themselves.

They start pitches with, “Our company was founded in 1858…” or “We’ve won multiple industry awards…” hoping credibility alone will win the deal. But the truth is, as author and consultant Steve Woodruff says, “The buyer is always tuned in to one station—WIFM: What’s In It For Me.” If they don’t hear the answer fast, they check out. 

84% of business buyers expect sales reps to act as trusted advisors—but 73% say most sales interactions feel transactional. — Salesforce

The data backs this up. According to Salesforce, 84% of business buyers expect sales reps to act as trusted advisors—but 73% say most sales interactions feel transactional. Why? Because reps aren’t personalizing the conversation. They’re talking about themselves instead of the buyer.

Fix It: Flip the Focus

To grab attention from the start, make the conversation about the buyer. 

Instead of saying, “We’re the leading provider of AI-powered sales tools,” say this:

“Sales teams waste hours every week searching for the right content. What if you could instantly access the best messaging for any situation, on demand?” 

This small shift changes everything. It shows the buyer that you understand their problem before you pitch a solution. And that’s how you create a sales value proposition that resonates. 

Mistake #2: Listing Features Instead of Benefits

Buyers don’t buy products. They buy outcomes.

But sales reps tend to rattle off a list of product features, expecting buyers to connect the dots. They don’t.

Imagine pitching an AI-powered sales tool like this: “Our platform uses AI-driven analytics, real-time coaching, and automated content recommendations.”

That sounds impressive—but so what?

Buyers aren’t sitting around thinking, I need AI-driven analytics today! What they want is faster deal cycles, higher conversion rates, and fewer lost opportunities. When you lead with features instead of benefits, you force buyers to do the mental work of figuring out why they should care. Most won’t bother.

This is exactly why 73% of buyers say sales interactions feel transactional. Too many reps focus on what the product does instead of how it solves a problem.

Fix It: Translate Features into Buyer Benefits

Every feature you mention needs to answer one question: “So what?” 

Instead of saying, “Our platform uses AI-driven analytics,” try saying this:

“Our AI-driven analytics identify the highest-converting messaging, so your reps always know exactly what to say to close more deals.”

See the difference? One is a feature dump. The other is a clear, buyer-focused benefit.

The best sales reps don’t sell specs. They sell outcomes. Lead with the benefit, then back it up with the feature. That’s how you make your sales value proposition stick.

Mistake #3: Assuming the Buyer Understands the Value

You see the value of your product. You know exactly how it helps. The problem? Your buyer doesn’t—unless you make it unmistakably clear.

In most cases, sales reps assume buyers will instantly “get it.” They fire off a sales pitch and expect the prospect to connect the dots. But buyers are busy. They’re distracted. If your value isn’t obvious, they’ll move on.

I learned this lesson the hard way. Early in my career, I was presenting my sales training program to an executive at EMC. He wanted to hear my presentation before I did it for his sales team. The reason: to make sure what I said was relevant to his team. So, I walked him through my approach from beginning to end.

When I finished, I asked him, “So, what do you think?”

He replied, “What’s the purpose of your presentation?”

“To help salespeople stretch their comfort zone.”

“Okay. But so what? Why should they care about that?”

That question stopped me in my tracks. But he was right. I had assumed he saw the value in what I was presenting—and that his team would, too. He didn’t. And that was my failure—not his.

Fix It: Make Your Value Unmistakable

Want your sales value proposition to land? Don’t assume—spell it out. Tie your solution directly to the buyer’s biggest challenge.

For example, instead of saying, “Our tool integrates with your CRM,” try saying this:

“Because our tool integrates with your CRM, your reps will spend less time on admin work and more time selling—boosting productivity by 30%.”

The second version doesn’t just state a fact. It answers the buyer’s unspoken question: “So what?” 

Top salespeople don’t leave value to chance. They make it impossible to miss. If your buyer has to figure out the impact on their own, you’ve already lost.

Mistake #4: Ignoring Emotional Drivers in Decision-Making

Sales isn’t just about logic. It’s about emotion.

Buyers like to think they make rational, fact-based decisions. The reality, however, is people make emotional decisions and justify their decisions with logic.

The mistake many sales reps make is they ignore emotion and focus only on facts, figures, and ROI calculations. They forget that logic alone rarely closes a deal. If numbers were enough, every buyer would simply pick the lowest-cost option. But they don’t—because purchases aren’t just about price. They’re about creating a sense of certainty, trust, and reducing risk. It’s also about having a vision about what the product or service  can actually do. 

Think about why Apple can charge premium prices when cheaper alternatives exist. It’s not just about specs—it’s about status, simplicity, and the feeling of owning the best. 

Fix It: Sell the Feeling, Not Just the Facts

The best salespeople understand that emotion drives buying behavior. They connect their sales value proposition to what the buyer truly cares about—security, ease, prestige, or peace of mind. 

Instead of saying, “Our cybersecurity solution has AI-driven threat detection,” try saying this:

“With our cybersecurity solution, you’ll sleep better at night knowing your company is protected against evolving threats—without lifting a finger.”

Both statements describe the same product, but only one taps into what actually matters to the buyer.

Facts tell. Emotion sells. If you’re only pitching logic, you’re making your buyer work too hard to care. Make them feel the value, and they’ll be far more likely to say yes.

Mistake #5: Delivering a One-Size-Fits-All Pitch

Every buyer is different. Every deal is different. So why do so many sales reps use the same pitch every time?

It’s easy to fall into the habit of delivering a canned sales value proposition—especially if it’s worked before. But what resonates with one buyer might completely miss the mark with another. If your pitch doesn’t speak directly to their specific challenges, it won’t land.

Buyers can tell when they’re getting a generic sales script instead of a tailored conversation. And when that happens, they check out. Fast. 

Fix It: Customize Every Conversation

Top salespeople never deliver the same pitch twice. They adjust their messaging based on who they’re talking to, what industry they’re in, and what challenges they’re facing. 

Instead of saying, “Our solution helps companies like yours improve efficiency,” try saying this: 

“Right now, manufacturing teams like yours are losing hours every week due to outdated systems. Our solution eliminates that wasted time, so your team can focus on hitting production targets.” 

The second version makes it clear: I understand your world, your challenges, and what success looks like for you. That’s how you get buyers to listen. 

A strong sales value proposition isn’t just about what you sell. It’s about making every buyer feel like your solution was built specifically for them.

The Game-Changer: Using Technology to Strengthen Your Sales Value Proposition

Even the best sales reps don’t get their pitch perfect on the first try. The difference? Top performers refine, adjust, and continually improve based on real buyer interactions. 

But here’s the challenge: Most sales teams don’t have a structured way to analyze and optimize their messaging. That’s where technology comes in. AI-powered sales enablement platforms help sellers:

• Personalize pitches at scale by surfacing the most relevant messaging for each buyer.
• Get real-time sales coaching with AI-driven feedback on tone, clarity, and buyer engagement.
• Learn from top performers by capturing and sharing winning sales conversations.
• Test and refine messaging through video practice, AI-powered role-play exercise, and peer feedback before going live with buyers.

Instead of relying on gut instinct, sales teams can use data and AI-driven insights to fine-tune their sales value proposition—so every conversation lands with impact.

Test Your Sales Value Proposition

If buyers aren’t responding to your pitch, the problem isn’t your product. It’s how you’re positioning it.

A weak sales value proposition makes buyers tune out. A strong one makes them lean in. The difference comes down to how well you communicate the impact of what you’re selling.

• Make it about them—not you.
• Sell benefits, not just features.
• Spell out the value—don’t assume they see it.
• Tap into emotion—because logic alone won’t close the deal.
• Customize every conversation—because one size fits all doesn’t work.
• And don’t rely on trial and error. Use technology to refine, test, and perfect your messaging.  

So, here’s your challenge: Put your sales value proposition to the test. Go back to your pitch, your emails, your messaging. Ask yourself:

If I were the buyer, would I care?

Does this answer “So what?” in the first 10 seconds?

Is the value crystal clear—or am I making them figure it out?

If you’re not 100% sure, it’s time to refine. 

---

About the Author: Mark Magnacca is President and Co-Founder of Allego. He is also the author of So What? How to Communicate What Really Matters to Your Audience and co-author of Digital Sales Revolution, which provides a roadmap to the shifting digital selling universe, and Mastering Virtual Selling: Orchestrating Sales Success, a book that transformed virtual selling strategies.

---

Take Your Sales Messaging to the Next Level

Download a free excerpt fromSo What? How to Communicate What Really Matters to Your Audience and learn how to answer the only question that matters: “So what?”—and make every sales conversation count. Download the Free Chapter.